• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 0
[email protected]
Contact form
Patent- & Rechtsanwaltskanzlei

Patent- & Rechtsanwaltskanzlei

  • Deutsch

+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 0

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • xing
  • Email
MENUMENU
  • Services
    • Advice On Protective IP Rights
    • Patent Application /TM Registration
    • Enforcement Of IP Rights
    • Defence Against IP Rights Enforcement
    • Costs
  • Company
    • Fields of Law
      • Patent Law
      • Utility Model Law
      • Employees’ Inventions
      • Trademark Law
      • Design Law
      • Trademark and Product Piracy
      • Expert Opinions
    • Our Law Firm
      • Dr. Karl-Hermann Meyer-Dulheuer
      • Dr. Tim Meyer-Dulheuer
      • Dr. Klaus Zimmermann
      • Zhichao Ying
      • Clara Elinor Grünewald
    • Commitment
  • Contact
    • Where To Find Us
    • Write us!
    • Request call back
  • Blog

Gold-plated bottle shape protected as 3D union trademark

9. May 2019

The shape of a gold-plated bottle as well as a pink coated bottle can be protected as a 3D Union trademark. So decided yesterday the court of the European Union. This is another important judgment for three-dimensional union marks in the packaging sector.

Shape of a bottle as 3D union trademark

Golden shape of bottle 3D Union trademark

This decision is based on two invalidity proceedings relating to trade mark protection for the shape of a bottle with a special coating. In 2013 Sandro Bottega (Colle Umberto, Italy) twice applied for a 3D union mark with coated bottle shapes, one with a gilded colour, one with a shimmering pink colour. Both marks were registered in Nice Class 33 for, inter alia, ‘alcoholic beverages; spirits’ and many other beverages.

Plaintiff Vinicola Tombacco (VI.TO.) Srl (Trebaseleghe, Italy) brought actions for annulment against these two trade mark registrations. These actions were dismissed both by the EUIPO and now by the European Court. It is undisputed between the Plaintiff and EUIPO that the shape of the bottles called “collio” can be considered as a simple variant of shapes that have existed since “unimaginable” times.

However, the plaintiff argued that the golden colour completely covering the bottle of the mark gives significant value to the goods concerned. If the Court had confirmed this, it would have precluded registration of the mark. Article 7(1)(e)(iii) of Regulation No 207/2009 provides that signs consisting exclusively of the shape which confers substantial value on the product are not to be registered.

European Court confirms trademark protection

However, the CJEU rejected the argument because the colour is not comparable with a feature of the shape of the sign, which the plaintiff relied on (EU:T:2019:297). Therefore, the decisions of the Board of Appeal which do not concern the shape of the sign are not relevant here, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) held. However, if the applicant had raised another objection, the mirror effect of the surface of the bottle resulting from the polishing of the glass should have been examined, within the meaning of the regulation, as to whether it constituted a particular design element.

The Court also pointed out that the mark in dispute consists of the shape of the packaging of the goods concerned and not of the shape of the goods themselves. Beverages can naturally not be sold in the same condition as they are and therefore require packaging, the court added.

pink shape of bottleIn his second action for annulment, Tombacco put forward a further argument against the 3 D Union trade mark of the shimmering pink bottle shape. The Board of Appeal failed to take account of the fact that the use of paint on bottles of sparkling wine is intended to preserve the organoleptic properties of the contents by acting as a barrier to the oxidation process. Therefore, the combination of the shape of the bottle and its respective colour would aim at achieving a technical effect.

Elements which are assessed as technically and functionally conditional are excluded as a characteristic indicating origin (pursuant to Article 7(1)(e)(ii) of Regulation No 207/2009). In addition, Regulation 2015/2424 introduced the possibility for a trade mark to function on the basis of a characteristic other than the shape of the product. However, that Regulation was not applicable at the time of the facts in question.

CJEU on the shape of the sign

The European Court rejected the plaintiff’s reasoning (EU:T:2019:299). The CJEU pointed out that, in the context of trade mark law, the term “shape” is generally understood to mean a series of lines or contours which define the product concerned in space, so that a colour cannot in itself form a shape without being defined in space. Accordingly, the applicant cannot reasonably rely on the technical effect of the colour, which, moreover, has not been demonstrated.

Finally, Mr Tombacco also referred to the Opinion of Advocate General Szpunar in Louboutin and Christian Louboutin (C-163/16, EU:C:2018:64), that “the combination of colour and shape” is likely to be affected by the prohibition of “shape which confers substantial value on products”.

The CJEU also rejected this argument as inadmissible and in any case as ineffective. As already set out in the reasoning on the ‘essential value’ of the contested mark, the Board of Appeal’s decisions which do not concern the shape of the sign are not relevant here. In addition, the CJEU stressed that, as a court of first instance (CFI), it is not bound by the Opinion of the Advocate General or by his reasoning, any more than the ECJ, which in the Louboutin case had in any case not followed the Opinion of the Advocate General.

The European Court therefore dismissed the action for invalidity and upheld the trade mark registrations of the two bottle shapes coated in colour and with a mirror effect.

Maybe also interesting:

  • Louboutin victorious in the battle over the famous red sole
  • Bottle shape protected as 3D unionmark
  • Sign of a colour combination is no colour mark

 

Would you also like to protect your trademark or brand?

Our lawyers are experienced in trademark and patent law, national and international law.

 

 

 

Sources for text and picture:

Judgement European Court EU:T:2019:299 |  Judgement European Court EuG EU:T:2019:297

  • share  518 
  • share 
  • share 
  • tweet  
  • share 

Category iconTrademark Law Tag iconCJEU,  European Court,  CFI,  Louboutin,  shape,  colour,  bottle shape,  Union trademark,  Form,  invalidity proceedings,  EU:T:2019:297,  EU:T:2019:299,  3D union trademark,  liquids,  shape of the packaging,  Beverages

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

More articles about: Trademark Law

All articles

Blog Menu

  • Design Law
  • Healthcare & Lifesciences
  • International Intellectual Property
  • Licenses
  • News from our law firm
  • Overall
  • Patent Law
  • Product- and Trademark piracy
  • Trademark Law
This form uses Google Recaptcha.

You must accept cookies from Google recaptcha to use this form.

More information can be found in our privacy policy.

load form

Recent Posts

  • Bacardi wins in trademark dispute Vodka 42 BELOW 20. January 2021
  • HALLOUMI vs. BBQLOUMI: Cyprus loses again in trademark dispute 20. January 2021
  • Short word marks and similarity: First letter is not everything 19. January 2021
  • Where in Europe is a patent application worthwhile? 18. January 2021

Fields of Law

  • Patent Law
  • Utility Model Law
  • Employees’ Inventions
  • Trademark Law
  • Design Law
  • Trademark and Product Piracy
  • Expert Opinions
  • Costs

Das könnte Sie auch interessieren:

20. January 2021
Bacardi wins in trademark dispute Vodka 42 BELOW

Bacardi wins in trademark dispute Vodka 42 BELOW

20. January 2021
HALLOUMI vs. BBQLOUMI: Cyprus loses again in trademark dispute

HALLOUMI vs. BBQLOUMI: Cyprus loses again in trademark dispute

19. January 2021
Short word marks and similarity: First letter is not everything

Short word marks and similarity: First letter is not everything

15. January 2021
HOTTINGER vs. HOTTINGUER: trademark dispute over financial services

HOTTINGER vs. HOTTINGUER: trademark dispute over financial services

12. January 2021
US Trademark Law Modernized (TMA): Faster and Better for Trademark Challenges

US Trademark Law Modernized (TMA): Faster and Better for Trademark Challenges

7. January 2021
Nice Classification 2021: Robots, Joysticks and Automation

Nice Classification 2021: Robots, Joysticks and Automation

Footer

Contact

Franklinstr. 61-63
D-60486 Frankfurt am Main
Germany

+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 0
+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 199
[email protected]

Customer Reviews

Meyer-Dulheuer MD Legal Patentanwälte PartG mbB Patentrecht, Markenrecht, Eigentum hat 4,78 von 5 Sternen 23 Bewertungen auf ProvenExpert.com

Fields of Law

  • Patent Law
  • Utility Model Law
  • Employees’ Inventions
  • Trademark Law
  • Design Law
  • Trademark and Product Piracy
  • Expert Opinions
  • Costs

Law Firm

  • Request non-binding call back
  • Info secure emails
  • Company
  • Our Law Firm
  • ISO Certificate
  • Privacy Policy
  • Data handling for clients
  • Imprint

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • xing
  • Email

Newsletter Signup

This form uses Google Recaptcha.

You must accept cookies from Google recaptcha to use this form.

More information can be found in our privacy policy.

load form

© Patent- & Rechtsanwaltskanzlei Meyer-Dulheuer MD Legal Patentanwälte PartG mbB

Kontaktformular

 

Rufen Sie uns an, schicken Sie uns eine Mail oder füllen Sie das Kontaktformular aus.

+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 0
[email protected]

This form uses Google Recaptcha.

You must accept cookies from Google recaptcha to use this form.

More information can be found in our privacy policy.

load form

Contact Form

 

Give us a call, send us an email or fill out the contact form.

+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 0
[email protected]

This form uses Google Recaptcha.

You must accept cookies from Google recaptcha to use this form.

More information can be found in our privacy policy.

load form