• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 0
[email protected]
Contact form
Patent- & Rechtsanwaltskanzlei

Patent- & Rechtsanwaltskanzlei

  • Deutsch

+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 0

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • xing
  • Email
MENUMENU
  • Services
    • Advice On Protective IP Rights
    • Patent Application /TM Registration
    • Enforcement Of IP Rights
    • Defence Against IP Rights Enforcement
    • Costs
  • Company
    • Fields of Law
      • Patent Law
      • Utility Model Law
      • Employees’ Inventions
      • Trademark Law
      • Design Law
      • Trademark and Product Piracy
      • Expert Opinions
    • Our Law Firm
      • Dr. Karl-Hermann Meyer-Dulheuer
      • Dr. Tim Meyer-Dulheuer
      • Dr. Klaus Zimmermann
      • Zhichao Ying
      • Clara Elinor Grünewald
    • Commitment
  • Contact
    • Where To Find Us
    • Write us!
    • Request call back
  • Blog

Second-hand E-books in virtual marketplace = communication to the public

10. January 2020

Just before Christmas, Europe’s highest court handed down an important ruling on copyright and e-books. Is a virtual marketplace for second-hand e-books an infringement of copyright?

second-hand E-BookTwo Dutch associations, the NUV and GAU, were commissioned by several Dutch publishers in 2014 to take action against Tom Kabinet, the operator of an online marketplace for used e-books. The publishers and associations believed that this was a copyright infringement against the sale of illegally downloaded e-books.

On 1 June 2015, Tom Kabinet changed the services offered until then and replaced them with a Tom Kabinet reading club. The Reading Club offered its members “used” e-books in return for a sum of money, which were either purchased by Tom Kabinet or donated free of charge to Tom Kabinet by the members of the Club. In the latter case, these members had to provide the download link for the book in question and declare that they had not kept a copy of the book. Tom Kabinet then uploaded the e-book from the retailer’s website and added his own digital watermark to the e-book to confirm that it was a legally purchased copy.

As of November 2015, there was no longer be a monthly fee for membership in the Reading Club, but instead members of the Reading Club needed “credits” to receive an e-book from the Reading Club. These credits could be acquired by donating or selling an e-book and also when ordering.

The publishers and the associations NUV and GAU also saw a continuing copyright infringement in this process and applied for an injunction against the Reading Club. In particular, Tom Kabinet’s Reading Club was alleged to be engaged in the unauthorised distribution and reproduction of e-books to the public. This is because making an e-book accessible is usually accompanied by a licence for use which only permits the reading of the e-book by the user who has downloaded the e-book in question with his own device.

Dutch court did not find the act of distribution to be clear

In an interlocutory judgment, the Rechtbank Den Haag (Court of The Hague, Netherlands) rejected this allegation. Tom Kabinet’s offer does not constitute communication to the public of those works within the meaning of Article 3(1) of the Directive. Nevertheless, it is not clear whether making an e-book available by downloading for use for an indefinite period of time, for which payment is required, constitutes an act of distribution within the meaning of Article 4(1) of Directive 2001/29. The Rechtbank referred this question to the highest European court (ECJ) for a decision.

ECJ sees action by the reading club as communication to the public

Just before Christmas, the ECJ ruled in this case. In order to be classified as “communication to the public”, it is necessary that a protected work be reproduced using a technical process different from those previously used or for a “new public” , according to case law of ECJ (Stichting Brein judgment, C-610/15). In the present case of the reading club Tom Kabinet, the reproduction, as carried out by Tom Kabinet, is directed at a new public, the court explained.

In the light of the foregoing, the answer to the question referred must be that the making available to the public, by means of downloading, of an e-book for permanent use to the public falls within the concept of ‘communication to the public’ and, in particular, within the concept of ‘making works available to members of the public at a place and at a time individually chosen by them’ within the meaning of Article 3(1) of Directive 2001/29.

Any provision of an online service requires consent

The Court explained that the question of exhaustion did not arise in relation to services in general or online services in particular, since, unlike CD-ROM or CD-I, where the intellectual property is embodied in a physical medium, any provision of an online service is in fact an act requiring consent where copyright or a related right so provides.

It could not be assumed that the making available of a book on a material medium and the making available of an e-book were comparable in economic and functional terms, the ECJ stated. The non-physical digital copies would – unlike books on a physical carrier – namely not be deteriorated by use, so that the “used” copies would be a perfect substitute for new copies.

Would you also like to protect a trademark? Or do you need help with copyright law?

Each case is considered individually and carefully by us. Please feel free to request a call-back!


 

Sources: 

Judgement ECJ E-Books  C:2019:1111

Image:

Free-Photos / pixabay.com / CCO License

  • share  
  • share 
  • share 
  • tweet  
  • share 

Category iconInternational Intellectual Property,  Product- and Trademark piracy Tag iconECJ,  e-books,  used e-books,  Virtual market for second-hand e‑books,  Exhaustion

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

More articles about: International Intellectual Property

All articles

Blog Menu

  • Design Law
  • Healthcare & Lifesciences
  • International Intellectual Property
  • Licenses
  • News from our law firm
  • Overall
  • Patent Law
  • Product- and Trademark piracy
  • Trademark Law
This form uses Google Recaptcha.

You must accept cookies from Google recaptcha to use this form.

More information can be found in our privacy policy.

load form

Recent Posts

  • Thermomix infringement by Lidl: Will Monsieur Cuisine still exist? 25. January 2021
  • Time limit missed for remedying deficiencies at EUIPO 25. January 2021
  • Bacardi wins in trademark dispute Vodka 42 BELOW 20. January 2021
  • HALLOUMI vs. BBQLOUMI: Cyprus loses again in trademark dispute 20. January 2021

Fields of Law

  • Patent Law
  • Utility Model Law
  • Employees’ Inventions
  • Trademark Law
  • Design Law
  • Trademark and Product Piracy
  • Expert Opinions
  • Costs

Das könnte Sie auch interessieren:

25. January 2021
Thermomix infringement by Lidl: Will Monsieur Cuisine still exist?

Thermomix infringement by Lidl: Will Monsieur Cuisine still exist?

18. December 2020
EUIPO ‘SME Fund’: grant promotes SME applications for IP rights

EUIPO ‘SME Fund’: grant promotes SME applications for IP rights

17. December 2020
ECJ and Morbier: Designation of origin protects more than the name

ECJ and Morbier: Designation of origin protects more than the name

11. December 2020
Illegal videos on Youtube – no disclosure of the e-mail

Illegal videos on Youtube – no disclosure of the e-mail

3. December 2020
Käpt’n Iglo: maritime advertising in court

Käpt’n Iglo: maritime advertising in court

19. November 2020
ECJ: Video reproduction is not a phonogram

ECJ: Video reproduction is not a phonogram

Footer

Contact

Franklinstr. 61-63
D-60486 Frankfurt am Main
Germany

+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 0
+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 199
[email protected]

Customer Reviews

Meyer-Dulheuer MD Legal Patentanwälte PartG mbB Patentrecht, Markenrecht, Eigentum hat 4,78 von 5 Sternen 23 Bewertungen auf ProvenExpert.com

Fields of Law

  • Patent Law
  • Utility Model Law
  • Employees’ Inventions
  • Trademark Law
  • Design Law
  • Trademark and Product Piracy
  • Expert Opinions
  • Costs

Law Firm

  • Request non-binding call back
  • Info secure emails
  • Company
  • Our Law Firm
  • ISO Certificate
  • Privacy Policy
  • Data handling for clients
  • Imprint

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • xing
  • Email

Newsletter Signup

This form uses Google Recaptcha.

You must accept cookies from Google recaptcha to use this form.

More information can be found in our privacy policy.

load form

© Patent- & Rechtsanwaltskanzlei Meyer-Dulheuer MD Legal Patentanwälte PartG mbB

Kontaktformular

 

Rufen Sie uns an, schicken Sie uns eine Mail oder füllen Sie das Kontaktformular aus.

+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 0
[email protected]

This form uses Google Recaptcha.

You must accept cookies from Google recaptcha to use this form.

More information can be found in our privacy policy.

load form

Contact Form

 

Give us a call, send us an email or fill out the contact form.

+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 0
[email protected]

This form uses Google Recaptcha.

You must accept cookies from Google recaptcha to use this form.

More information can be found in our privacy policy.

load form