• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 0
[email protected]
Contact form
Patent- & Rechtsanwaltskanzlei

Patent- & Rechtsanwaltskanzlei

  • Deutsch

+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 0

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • xing
  • Email
MENUMENU
  • Services
    • Advice On Protective IP Rights
    • Patent Application /TM Registration
    • Enforcement Of IP Rights
    • Defence Against IP Rights Enforcement
    • Costs
  • Company
    • Fields of Law
      • Patent Law
      • Utility Model Law
      • Employees’ Inventions
      • Trademark Law
      • Design Law
      • Trademark and Product Piracy
      • Expert Opinions
    • Our Law Firm
      • Dr. Karl-Hermann Meyer-Dulheuer
      • Dr. Tim Meyer-Dulheuer
      • Dr. Klaus Zimmermann
      • Zhichao Ying
      • Clara Elinor Grünewald
    • Commitment
  • Contact
    • Where To Find Us
    • Write us!
    • Request call back
  • Blog

Undisclosed disclaimer: permissible extension in German patent law?

26. October 2017

Subsequent entry in the disclaimer, a so-called undisclosed disclaimer, may constitute a permissible extension to the patent claim already granted. But this extension is not permitted for the grant procedure of a patent, decided the Federal Supreme Court.

A few weeks ago, the Federal Supreme Court (BGH) ruled in the case of “phosphatidylcholine” (25.7.2017 – X ZB 5/16). The subsequent inclusion of a feature in a disclaimer, according to which the preparation may not contain a particular substance, was considered an admissible extension, but the application for a patent grant on the basis of the undisclosed disclaimer was rejected.

The legal position of “undisclosed disclaimer”

cremeA feature not originally disclosed may remain in the patent claim if its insertion leads to a limitation of the subject matter of the application. However, this does not apply to the grant of a patent, but only to opposition and nullity proceedings. This has already been judged in previous decisions. The Federal Supreme Court now stressed that a patent application must be rejected if the claim made differs from the original version filed for the patent application and this deficiency is not remedied by the applicant, even if requested by the Examining Section. This law serves the purpose of legal certainty and excludes that a patent with an inadmissibly changed content is granted.

Background in the case of phosphatidylcholine

In the disclaimer for skin care products, the cosmetic use of the preparation is mentioned, which in each case contains up to 30% by weight of table salt and glycerine. Their effect on the barrier properties of the skin was described in detail. Furthermore, the description contained a list of numerous other substances which may or may not be present in the preparation, depending on the intended uses.

Only afterwards did the applicant add indications to the disclaimer that the preparations must not contain phosphatidylcholine.

Original version is decisive for “undisclosed disclaimer”

The description in the original version and the nature of the deviation from the later version is decisive in determining whether an extension is admissible or not. For example, if the original version contains indications that the exclusive existence of the patent object from the above-mentioned elements has particular advantages, an extension is not permitted. This was not the case in the present decision on phosphatidycholine. Phosphatidylcholine is subsequently disclosed as a possible component of the preparation, or, more precisely, excluded as a possible component. And the original version of the application documents does not indicate that this component is necessary or advantageous for the preparation.

As there is no additional technical effect due to the exclusion of phosphatidycholine or because any experts receive new technical information, the Federal Supreme Court finds in this case a permissible extension.

Finally in view of the special protection of the public and the caesura caused by the grant of a patent, an undisclosed disclaimer in a granted patent claim is to be judged differently from a claim in the examination procedure for the grant of the patent.

 

Do you need help in German or European patent law ?

Our lawyers advise you individually and together with you develop the right strategy to protect your brand.

CAT-call_en

 

Source:

Text: Judgement of the Federal Supreme Court, July 2017

EPO: Applying G 2/10 to undisclosed disclaimers

Photos:  Alicja_J /pixabay.com / CC0 License    ||   Mikali / pixabay.com / CC0-License

  • share  
  • share 
  • share 
  • tweet  
  • share 

Category iconPatent Law Tag iconPatent,  disclaimer

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

More articles about: Patent Law

All articles

Blog Menu

  • Design Law
  • Healthcare & Lifesciences
  • International Intellectual Property
  • Licenses
  • News from our law firm
  • Overall
  • Patent Law
  • Product- and Trademark piracy
  • Trademark Law
This form uses Google Recaptcha.

You must accept cookies from Google recaptcha to use this form.

More information can be found in our privacy policy.

load form

Recent Posts

  • Own trademark application fails – despite comparable trademarks: Equal treatment? 5. March 2021
  • Intel to pay 2.2 billion in damages – to VLSI / Fortress Investment 5. March 2021
  • BGH “FRAND II” – SEP Licensing as Distributor? 2. March 2021
  • Suspension of infringement proceedings 1. March 2021

Fields of Law

  • Patent Law
  • Utility Model Law
  • Employees’ Inventions
  • Trademark Law
  • Design Law
  • Trademark and Product Piracy
  • Expert Opinions
  • Costs

Das könnte Sie auch interessieren:

5. March 2021
Intel to pay 2.2 billion in damages – to VLSI / Fortress Investment

Intel to pay 2.2 billion in damages – to VLSI / Fortress Investment

2. March 2021
BGH “FRAND II” – SEP Licensing as Distributor?

BGH “FRAND II” – SEP Licensing as Distributor?

26. February 2021
Action against a patent already expired

Action against a patent already expired

18. February 2021
EPO practice of national patent offices – more uniform

EPO practice of national patent offices – more uniform

15. February 2021
Employee’s invention in insolvency

Employee’s invention in insolvency

12. February 2021
Equivalence ruling of BGH: ‘Equivalent means’ in case Crane arm

Equivalence ruling of BGH: ‘Equivalent means’ in case Crane arm

Footer

Contact

Franklinstr. 61-63
D-60486 Frankfurt am Main
Germany

+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 0
+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 199
[email protected]

Customer Reviews

Meyer-Dulheuer MD Legal Patentanwälte PartG mbB Patentrecht, Markenrecht, Eigentum hat 4,78 von 5 Sternen 23 Bewertungen auf ProvenExpert.com

Fields of Law

  • Patent Law
  • Utility Model Law
  • Employees’ Inventions
  • Trademark Law
  • Design Law
  • Trademark and Product Piracy
  • Expert Opinions
  • Costs

Law Firm

  • Request non-binding call back
  • Info secure emails
  • Company
  • Our Law Firm
  • ISO Certificate
  • Privacy Policy
  • Data handling for clients
  • Imprint

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • xing
  • Email

Newsletter Signup

This form uses Google Recaptcha.

You must accept cookies from Google recaptcha to use this form.

More information can be found in our privacy policy.

load form

© Patent- & Rechtsanwaltskanzlei Meyer-Dulheuer MD Legal Patentanwälte PartG mbB

Kontaktformular

 

Rufen Sie uns an, schicken Sie uns eine Mail oder füllen Sie das Kontaktformular aus.

+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 0
[email protected]

This form uses Google Recaptcha.

You must accept cookies from Google recaptcha to use this form.

More information can be found in our privacy policy.

load form

Contact Form

 

Give us a call, send us an email or fill out the contact form.

+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 0
[email protected]

This form uses Google Recaptcha.

You must accept cookies from Google recaptcha to use this form.

More information can be found in our privacy policy.

load form