• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 0
[email protected]
Contact form
Patent- & Rechtsanwaltskanzlei

Patent- & Rechtsanwaltskanzlei

  • Deutsch

+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 0

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • xing
  • Email
MENUMENU
  • Services
    • Advice On Protective IP Rights
    • Patent Application /TM Registration
    • Enforcement Of IP Rights
    • Defence Against IP Rights Enforcement
    • Costs
  • Company
    • Fields of Law
      • Patent Law
      • Utility Model Law
      • Employees‘ Inventions
      • Trademark Law
      • Design Law
      • Trademark and Product Piracy
      • Expert Opinions
    • Our Law Firm
      • Dr. Karl-Hermann Meyer-Dulheuer
      • Dr. Tim Meyer-Dulheuer
      • Dr. Klaus Zimmermann
      • Zhichao Ying
      • Dr. Christoph Hölscher
    • Commitment
  • Contact
    • Where To Find Us
    • Write us!
    • Request call back
  • Blog

ECJ: IP address no ‘address’ of YouTube users

14. July 2020

Illegal uploading of videos or files to YouTube violates the intellectual property rights of the authors and owners of these files. In this case, the question of YouTube’s obligation to provide information is a recurring theme: do the IP addresses or e-mail addresses of its users have to be disclosed? The ECJ says: No.

Youtube EuGH Urteil 'Adresse'The Highest European Court of Justice (ECJ) has therefore issued a landmark ruling on this. The IP address of users of YouTube and Google who upload illegal and infringing videos or files is not part of the ‘address’ in the sense of the relevant EU directive, nor is the user’s email address and telephone number, the ECJ ruled (EU:C:2020:542).

German Constantin Film Verleih vs. YouTube

In the main proceedings, the German company Constantin Film Verleih GmbH (known mainly for the film ‘Fack Ju Göhte’) brought an action before the German courts against YouTube and Google, the parent company of YouTube. YouTube refused to disclose the IP addresses, e-mail addresses and telephone numbers of its users to Constantin, even though these users had demonstrably infringed Contantin’s intellectual property rights by illegally uploading videos that had been viewed tens of thousands of times.

German Copyright Law and EU Directive

According to German copyright law, in such a case the injured party has a right to information in accordance with § 101 (2) sentence 1 no. 3 UrhG. This also applies against a person who has rendered services used for infringing activities on a commercial scale.

The information required includes the names and addresses of the corresponding infringers of copyright pursuant to § 101 (3) No. 1 UrhG.

A corresponding EU Directive 2004/48 also provides that “information on the origin and distribution channels of goods or services infringing an intellectual property right shall be provided by the infringer and/or any other person”.

In particular, the referring German court therefore asked the European Court of Justice to interpret Article 8(2)(a) of Directive 2004/48, linking it to the question whether the additional information requested by Constantin Film Verleih (IP addresses, e-mail addresses and telephone numbers of YouTube users) falls under the term “addresses” within the meaning of that provision.

ECJ ruling ‘address’ confirms Youtube

The ECJ denied this in its ‘Addresses’ judgment (EU:C:2020:542). An examination of other Union acts relating to the e-mail address or the IP address showed that none of these acts uses the term “address” – without further specification – to designate the telephone number, the IP address or the e-mail address, the Court said. Moreover, the protection of intellectual property was always to be weighed against the general interest of EU citizens.

As a result, the ECJ ruled that, as regards a user who has uploaded files infringing an intellectual property right, the term “addresses” does not refer to that user’s e-mail address and telephone number, nor to the IP address used for uploading those files or the IP address used when he last accessed the user account.

In principle, however, the EU Member States could nevertheless grant a more extensive right to information, the ECJ added, referring to Article 8(3)(a) of Directive 2004/48, subject to the condition that a reasonable balance between the various fundamental rights concerned is ensured and the principle of proportionality is respected.

This judgment therefore confirms that YouTube – and other major online platforms – do not disclose IP addresses, e-mail addresses and telephone numbers of their users, even if they have illegally downloaded or uploaded data.

Do you also want to protect intellectual property or copyright?

Our patent attorneys and IP attorneys will be happy to advise you. Please contact us if you are interested – we look forward to your call!


 

Sources:

ECJ judgement ‘address’, EU:C:2020:542

Image:

geralt | pixabay.com | CCO License

  • share  
  • share 
  • share 
  • tweet 
  • share 

Category iconCopyright,  International Intellectual Property Tag iconEU:C:2020:542,  infringement of copyright,  Youtube,  Directive 2004/48,  Constantin,  judgment 'address',  illegal upload,  judgment Youtube,  judgment,  user,  Constantin Film Distribution,  ECJ,  address,  obligation to provide information,  copyright,  addresses,  IP address,  IP addresses,  Google,  e-mail address,  Constantin Film,  right to information

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

More articles about: Copyright

All articles

Blog Menu

  • Design Law
  • Healthcare & Lifesciences
  • International Intellectual Property
  • Licenses
  • News from our law firm
  • Overall
  • Patent Law
  • Product- and Trademark piracy
  • Trademark Law

Recent Posts

  • BPatG: Patent claim of cancer drug on active substance as salt 7. March 2022
  • Grant for European IP Protection: SME Fund 2022 4. March 2022
  • CODE-X vs. Cody’s: Likelihood of confusion in drinks? 25. February 2022
  • EOS lip balm no 3D trademark – appeal before ECJ not admissible 24. February 2022

Fields of Law

  • Patent Law
  • Utility Model Law
  • Employees’ Inventions
  • Trademark Law
  • Design Law
  • Trademark and Product Piracy
  • Expert Opinions
  • Costs

Das könnte Sie auch interessieren:

4. March 2022
Grant for European IP Protection: SME Fund 2022

Grant for European IP Protection: SME Fund 2022

28. January 2022
CFI: Intel rebate system – Intel successfull in legal dispute

CFI: Intel rebate system – Intel successfull in legal dispute

18. January 2022
Bundling of NRW court jurisdiction for IT and renewables

Bundling of NRW court jurisdiction for IT and renewables

4. January 2022
Classifications 2022: IPC, Nice and Locarno

Classifications 2022: IPC, Nice and Locarno

30. December 2021
DPMA online services around New Year

DPMA online services around New Year

25. October 2021
ECJ: decompiling software to correct bugs

ECJ: decompiling software to correct bugs

Contact us or request a call back

+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 0
[email protected]
Request a call back

Footer

Contact

Torhaus Westhafen
Speicherstrasse 59
D – 60327 Frankfurt am Main
Deutschland
+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 0
+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 199
[email protected]

Office Hours
Moday – Friday:   08:00-18:00

Fields of Law

  • Patent Law
  • Utility Model Law
  • Employees’ Inventions
  • Trademark Law
  • Design Law
  • Trademark and Product Piracy
  • Expert Opinions
  • Costs

Law Firm

  • Request non-binding call back
  • Company
  • Our Law Firm
  • ISO Certificate
  • Privacy Policy
  • Data handling for clients
  • Imprint

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • xing
  • Email

Newsletter Signup

© Patent- & Rechtsanwaltskanzlei Meyer-Dulheuer MD Legal Patentanwälte PartG mbB

Contact Form

 

Give us a call, send us an email or fill out the contact form.

+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 0
[email protected]

Kontaktformular

 

Rufen Sie uns an, schicken Sie uns eine Mail oder füllen Sie das Kontaktformular aus.

+49 (0) 69 / 606 278 – 0
[email protected]