An invention may already be used in one's own business and still be considered patentable, and even a sale to third parties may be permissible under certain circumstances. But when is this obviously public prior use that excludes patentability?
skilled person
Sufficient disclosure for a European patent
The opposition against a European patent on sheet steel was rejected. This case is interesting in view of the sufficient disclosure for a European patent and the introduction of fresh grounds for opposition in ongoing proceedings, especially since the contested decision was insufficiently reasoned.

