A long known, old functional principle can be "non-obvious" and therefore inventive in the sense of patentability, the BGH ruled in its leading decision 'Laufradschnellspanner' - even if the functional principle is used in devices that have also been known for a long time.
inventive
Sensitive mobile robot – not patentable
In the field of robots and human-machine communication there is a lot of dynamism. The BPatG rejected a sensitive mobile robot that distances itself from humans in the event of signs of stress as not patentable due to lack of inventive step. For an expert, this patent claim was obvious.
Invalidity proceedings cover all subclaims
In an invalidity proceedings concerning a European patent, the BPatG decided on the continuation of the invalidity proceedings with regard to all subclaims, even if the patentee in the parallel proceedings bases the action there only on the main claim: a leading decision.


