The BGH has ruled on how purpose clauses in patent claims should be interpreted in X ZR 35/24. The decision confirms the case law from X ZB 9/09 and has far-reaching significance for patent holders and challengers. BGH Confirms: Purpose Clauses in Patent Claims Are No Free Pass How Ruling X ZR 35/24 Shapes the
European Patent
Opt-Out Deadline Approaching: Mistakes Patent Holders Must Avoid at the UPC
The clock is ticking: On 1 June 2030, the transitional period of the Unified Patent Court (UPC) expires. Patent holders who have not filed an effective opt-out for their European patents by then will permanently subject them to the exclusive jurisdiction of the UPC. Over 630,000 patents have already been opted out of
PAP is in force: UPC possible in 2022
It has been expected for years, and now the Unified Patent Court (UPC) is probably coming in 2022: The last phase of the construction of the UPC, the so-called PAP, came into force on 19 January 2022. So to say, the UPC is "born", now it has to become grown up.
2022 – and what about the UPC?
After the UK's departure it became a bit quiet around the Unified Patent Court of the EU states, which had been planned for years. Now is the new year 2022, and it is time to take a look: what about the UPC?
Vindication of national parts of a European patent
The right from a European patent with an Employee’s invention is regulated under § 60 EPC. Also, this applies as a standard for the vindication on a European bundle patent, is ruled by the German OLG Frankfurt, i.e. for claiming the transfer of illegally filed European patent rights. And: an upper signature instead of
UPC: German Federal Constitutional Court rejects complaint
Another hurdle against the long-awaited UPC ( European Unified Patent Court) has fallen: The Federal Constitutional Court rejects the appeal. A violation of fundamental rights was not sufficiently credible.
Enlarged Board of Appeal: Prohibition of double patenting
The Enlarged Board of Appeal has ruled on important issues of double patenting claiming priority: The prohibition of double patenting also applies to parent and divisional applications as well as applications claiming the same priority - in same destination states.
Biopatent on malting barley: appeal dismissed
The European Patent Office (EPO) has rejected an appeal against a patent on malting barley by the beer companies Heineken and Carlsberg. The core issue is that a bio-patent is allowed on mutations, but not on classical breeding.
Ranpak packaging system: patent restricted in GER
The BPatG ruled on an action for revocation against the patent ' Ranpak packaging system ': The patent on the Ranpak packaging system was maintained in GER with restrictions. This was because the automation of the packaging process had not been obvious to a person skilled in the art.
Solar patent declared invalid for GER
The Federal Patent Court has declared a European patent on solar systems to be invalid in Germany. The solar patent had been protected in Germany for 15 years and made claims relating to DC power sources and DC/AC converters. Now it was found to be without inventive step.
Hitachi patent partially invalid in GER: code distribution for mobile communication
Hitachi patent was partially declared invalid for DE and remains valid in auxiliary version: it is about the patent 'code distribution for mobile communication'. The case about the Hitachi patent is interesting because of the relevant topic for mobile communication - and because the patent has already expired.
Enlarged Board of Appeal: Mixed inventions with computer
The Enlarged Board of Appeal has ruled on mixed inventions involving a computer program. Once a computer program is running, even merely "potential" technical effects shall always be treated as real technical effects. This is relevant, among other things, for patent protection of an algorithm.
EPO practice of national patent offices – more uniform
Minimum grounds for oppositions against patents and formalities for designating the inventor: these two areas in the EPO practice of national patent offices are now uniform for EPO member states, the EPO reports.
Where in Europe is a patent application worthwhile?
If one applies for a patent in Europe, this must be applied for and, above all, paid for in each country; even an EU patent is a bundle of national patents. Therefore, it is worth considering in which countries a patent application would be worthwhile at all - all the more so after Brexit and with the prospect of the
BGH ‘Cigarette package’: Extension of undisclosed features in EU patent
In its 'Cigarette Package' ruling, the BGH changed the contrary decision of the BPatG: it was about the extension of undisclosed features in an EU patent. The BGH followed its previous case law and emphasized the compatibility of EU law and German patent law.














